Sell Your Car in
Georgetown, IN & Louisville, KY

Get a real offer in 45 seconds

Sell your car fast, safe and easy

We beat most online offers

Used cars, trucks

fact_check

No Strings Attached

Walk away anytime. Getting an offer doesn't mean you have to sell.

lock

100% Protected Privacy

Your personal information is always protected and never shared.

paid

Quick & Easy Payment

Accept your offer and receive payment promptly - no delays or hassle.

The Mike’s Car Store Process

Wondering how it all goes down? Our trade-in process is simple, trustworthy, and keeps you in control of your deal.

1.

Bring Your Car In

Get an appraisal online or drive to our dealership here in Georgetown.

Make sure it’s clean and that you have all the necessary documents (title, registration, and any loan payoff information).

2.

Get an Appraisal

We’ll inspect your car, take it for a quick test drive, and evaluate its condition.

We’ll also look at current market trends and values.
 

3.

Receive an Offer

Based on the appraisal, we’ll make you an offer. Don’t worry – we won’t lowball you like those other guys!

Plus, we offer $1,000 more than you’ll get from Carvana or CarMax.
 

4.

Accept and Get Paid

If you accept the offer, you can complete the sale on the spot.

We’ll handle all the paperwork, and you walk away with payment, either by check or as a credit toward your next vehicle.

We’re Here When You Need Us

Have a question about selling your car or want to talk through your options? Give us a call or stop by!

📞 (812) 940-6453

HOURS OF OPERATIONS

Mon – Thu

9AM – 7PM

Fri

9AM – 5PM

Sat

9AM – 4PM

Sun

Closed

The #1 Watched Car Salesman:
Chevy Dude

Mike's Car Store is owned and operated by the #1 Watched Car Salesman on the Planet, Mike Davenport, AKA: Chevy Dude! With over 20 years of experience in the automotive industry, Mike's expertise helps millions of people worldwide, showing them how to negotiate car deals, maneuver through car dealership red tape, and spot scams during a vehicle purchase.

format_quote

After months of frustration with large dealerships, we ran across Chevy Dude YouTube videos. Contacted Mike and Grant, who immediately recommended the perfect truck for our needs. They replaced and corrected things on their own. What dealership does that? Shipping driver from IN to CA was amazing. Super fun and amazing experience. Honest Mike is right. “Buying a car doesn’t have to suck!

Dawnlee A.

format_quote

This was one of the easiest and most enjoyable car-buying experiences we've ever had. If Mike's Car Store has the vehicle you're looking for, do yourself a favor and give them a chance - you won't be disappointed! Be sure to tell Cory that Heink sent you!

Heink R.

format_quote

Buying a vehicle from Miles Car Store was very simple and easy! Our salesperson, Grant, was so easy to talk to and made the whole car-buying experience seamless. We purchased a 2011 Honda CRV, and the detail job made it look brand new! Thank you so much; we highly recommend this place to anyone looking to purchase quality used cars!”

Luke D.

We Buy Cars From Drivers Across
Indiana and Kentucky

Mike's Car Store proudly buys cars from drivers throughout Southern Indiana and the Greater Louisville area. No matter where you're coming from, we’ll ensure you get the best return on your investment – without the scams! We pay up to $1,000 more than Carvana or CarMax, and take models from a wide range of automakers.

With over 20 years of experience helping folks all over the South have apositive dealership experience, we know how to get you more for your vehicle. Simply fill out our no-obligation online appraisal form to get started! We regularly purchase vehicles from drivers in:

check Georgetown, IN

check Louisville, KY

check New Albany, IN

check Clarksville, IN

check Jeffersonville, IN

check Floyds Knobs, IN

check Sellersburg, IN

check  Lexington, KY

check  Lyndon, KY

check Elizabeth, IN

check Lanesville, IN

check St. Matthews, KY

Sell My Car In Georgetown, IN:
Frequently Asked Questions

View All FAQs

How do I know how much my car is worth?

To know how much your car is worth, you'll need to consider its year, make, model, and mileage. Some brands retain their resale value better than others, and high mileage can lower their value.

Other factors that play a role include the vehicle's condition, whether it has been in an accident, interior and exterior upkeep, and the vehicle's maintenance record. Providing us with as much information as possible about your vehicle can help us ensure you receive the best appraisal value.

What is the advantage of selling a car to a dealership?

From advertising to paperwork, selling your vehicle privately requires a lot of time and effort. And while some dealers will try to lowball you, we'll handle everything on your behalf and work hard to get you the best value possible.

There's a reason more drivers from Georgetown, Louisville, Lexington, Jeffersontown, Floyd County, and other communities throughout Kentucky and Southern Indiana choose to work with Mike's Car Store for their car-buying and selling needs!

Can I sell my car if it is being financed?

Yes, you can sell your car even if it's being financed. Keep in mind that as long as the loan exists, the lender will have a lien on the car. This means that if you default on your payments, the lender has the right to repossess the car, even if you've sold it to a new owner. You can learn more about used-car financing in our helpful resource hub.

How can I maximize my trade-in value?

Getting the most for your trade-in comes down to preparation. Start by giving your vehicle a thorough clean — first impressions matter. Gather any maintenance records to show it's been well cared for, and consider fixing minor cosmetic or mechanical issues to improve its appraisal. It's also a good idea to research your vehicle's market value ahead of time using online tools, so you have a realistic expectation based on its condition, age, and mileage.

Should I trade in my vehicle or sell it privately?

While selling your vehicle privately can sometimes bring in a higher price, it often requires more time and effort to create listings, meet buyers, and negotiate. Trading in your current vehicle at a dealership is much more convenient and typically safer, since you avoid dealing with strangers. Plus, many drivers benefit from potential tax savings when trading in, which can help offset the price difference.

What do I need to bring to sell my car at Mike's Car Store?

Just bring a valid photo ID, your vehicle's title or lienholder information, current registration, and all available keys or key fobs. If you're still making payments, bring a recent loan payoff statement. Maintenance records are helpful, too! Our team will guide you through the paperwork to make the process as smooth as possible.

How do vehicle titles and lien payoffs work in Indiana and Kentucky?

Both Indiana and Kentucky require proper title documentation and lien releases before ownership can be transferred. Indiana sellers generally need to complete the title assignment, while Kentucky typically requires notarized signatures. If your vehicle is financed, the outstanding lien must also be addressed. At Mike's Car Store, we'll help you understand the necessary paperwork and navigate the process with confidence.

Can I sell a car that doesn't run or has mechanical damage?

Mike's Car Store can evaluate vehicles with mechanical issues, accident damage, cosmetic wear, or other problems to determine whether we can make an offer. Your vehicle's condition, history, and repair needs will factor into its appraisal. Contact our team to discuss your vehicle, especially if it isn't drivable.

How quickly will I get paid for my car?

At Mike's Car Store, we make selling your car fast and straightforward. Start with an online appraisal or visit our Georgetown dealership for an in-person evaluation. Once you've accepted our offer and completed the necessary paperwork, qualifying transactions can be finalized on the spot. Payment is available by check or trade-in credit, with timing depending on title and lien requirements.

How does Mike's Car Store's $1,000 More Than CarMax or Carvana offer work?

Simply bring us your competing offer and let our team evaluate your vehicle's condition, mileage, and market value. We'll explain your eligibility and available offer.

Contact Us

Leave us a voicemail
or send us a message

Give us a call!

8379 IN 64, Georgetown, IN 47122

Copyright © 2012-2026 Mike's Car Store. All Rights Reserved.
Use of this site is subject to: terms of use, privacy policy.